Ratchet clauses: can a market rent review reduce your rent?
A ratchet clause is a lease term that stops rent from falling at a rent review, so rent can only go up or stay the same. In a lease covered by retail tenancy legislation, every Australian state and territory restricts ratchets in some form, and in most of them a clause that prevents a market review reducing rent is void. The scope differs by state, so check the Act that applies to your lease before accepting a rent floor.
Have a lease or heads of agreement in front of you? Check it with the free preview.
What a ratchet clause is
A rent review resets the rent at set dates during the term. A fixed review increases rent by an agreed percentage. A CPI review moves rent with inflation. A market review resets rent to what the premises would let for today. The first two can only move rent one way by design. A market review can go either way, because markets fall as well as rise.
A ratchet clause removes the downside for the landlord. It says that whatever the market review produces, the new rent cannot be less than the rent payable immediately before the review. Some leases do the same thing less obviously: "the greater of the market rent and the current rent", "rent shall not decrease", or a review that the landlord may choose to run or skip.
The word "ratchet" comes from the mechanical device that turns one way and locks. A rent ratchet works the same way. Each upward review locks in, and no downward review is allowed to undo it.
Why it matters to a tenant
Suppose your rent is $120,000 a year and a market review at year three concludes that comparable shops now let for $105,000. Without a ratchet, your rent falls to $105,000. With a ratchet, it stays at $120,000. Over the remaining two years of a five-year term that is $30,000 of rent above market, and if the lease has an option, the inflated figure becomes the base for the next term as well.
A ratchet also changes the negotiating balance at review time. The landlord has nothing to lose from a market review, so there is no reason for it to compromise. A tenant facing a market review with a ratchet is paying for a valuation process that can only ever hurt it.
What the law says in each state and territory
Retail tenancy Acts deal with ratchets as part of their rules on how rent may be reviewed. The common pattern is that a lease must use a single method for each review and must not prevent a review that could reduce rent from doing so. The table summarises the position for leases covered by each Act. Coverage itself depends on the premises, the use and the exclusions in the Act.
| Jurisdiction | Position | Provision |
|---|---|---|
| Western Australia | A provision that purports to preclude the increase or reduction of market rent, or to limit how far market rent may move, is void. Each review must also specify a single basis. | Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 11(1), s 11(2)(c) |
| New South Wales | Base rent may only change by one method on each occasion, a "higher of two methods" clause is void, and a provision preventing a decrease at a market review is void. | Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW), s 18(3), s 18(4) |
| Victoria | A provision that prevents rent decreasing on a review is void. The Small Business Commission guidelines note this does not catch fixed percentage, index or fixed amount reviews, which only move one way by their nature. | Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic), s 35(3) |
| Queensland | Where the review basis allows rent to go down, a ratchet rent provision is void, including one that limits the size of a decrease or lets the landlord avoid a review. The main exception is a major lessee (5 or more shops) that gave a written notice before entering the lease. Check the transitional rules for older leases. | Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld), s 36A, s 27(8), s 134 |
| South Australia | Where a review may decrease rent, such as a market review, a provision preventing the decrease is void. | Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA), s 22(4) |
| Australian Capital Territory | A discretionary rent review clause is void, and the definition includes a provision preventing a decrease where the review might otherwise reduce rent. If the method is void and no alternative is agreed within 14 days of notice, rent becomes market rent. | Leases (Commercial and Retail) Act 2001 (ACT), s 46, s 49 |
| Northern Territory | A provision preventing or limiting a rent reduction is void, except in fixed percentage, index or fixed amount reviews. | Business Tenancies (Fair Dealings) Act 2003 (NT), s 28(3), s 28(4) |
| Tasmania | A provision that prohibits a rent decrease is invalid, as is one that combines two or more review methods for one adjustment. | Fair Trading (Code of Practice for Retail Tenancies) Regulations 1998 (Tas), cl 12(4), cl 12(5), cl 12(8) |
Summaries only. Each provision has conditions, exceptions and transitional rules not set out here. Read the current Act for your state and take advice before relying on any of them.
Where ratchets hide in a lease
Few leases use the word ratchet. Look for these patterns in the rent review clause and in any definitions it relies on.
- A floor: "the reviewed rent will not be less than the rent payable immediately before the review date".
- A choice of methods: "the greater of the CPI adjusted rent and the market rent".
- Landlord discretion: a market review that the landlord "may" initiate, so it is only run when the market has risen.
- A cap that only works one way: a collar that limits decreases but not increases.
- An option clause that fixes the first year of the new term at the last rent of the old term "or market rent, whichever is higher".
A clause can breach the single-basis rule and the ratchet rule at the same time. In several states the consequence is that the offending part is void and a statutory fallback decides the rent, which may not be the outcome either party wanted. It is better to fix the drafting before signing than to litigate the fallback later.
What to ask for
- Ask for the ratchet to be deleted and for the market review clause to state that rent may increase or decrease. If the lease is covered by a retail tenancy Act, say so and name the section.
- If the landlord wants certainty, propose a collar that limits movement in both directions by the same percentage, where the Act allows it. Queensland expressly permits caps; other Acts may not allow a floor at all, so check first.
- Check the option clause separately. The rent for the first year of a renewed term is often set by a market review, and a ratchet there is just as costly.
- Confirm which review applies on each date. One method per review date, written down, with no landlord discretion to choose.
- If the lease is not covered by retail tenancy legislation, the ratchet is simply a commercial term. Price it: a lease with a one-way review should carry a lower starting rent or a larger incentive than one without.
Check this clause in your own lease
LeaseRoom reads your lease or heads of agreement, flags clauses that carry risk for a tenant, refers to the relevant state or territory legislation and suggests wording to raise with your landlord. Start with a free preview.
Try the free previewFull review A$49 including GST per negotiation. No subscription. See pricing
Common questions
Are ratchet clauses illegal in Australia?
Retail leasing laws can void a rent floor where a review could otherwise lower the rent. The rules depend on the jurisdiction and the review method. In Queensland, for example, the major-lessee exception has specific notice and reporting requirements.
Does a CPI review with a zero floor count as a ratchet?
It depends on the state and review mechanism. Victoria and the Northern Territory have exceptions for some index-based reviews. Western Australia frames its rule around market rent. Check the wording of the Act for your state, and remember that a CPI review combined with a market review on the same date can breach the single-method rule.
What happens if my lease has a void ratchet clause?
The ratchet part of the clause has no effect, and the review operates without it. In some states a statutory fallback sets the rent if the whole review method is void. If you think a clause in a signed lease is void, get advice before withholding any rent.
Can the landlord simply not run the market review in a falling market?
Some leases give the landlord the choice. In Queensland a provision that lets the landlord avoid a review in order to prevent a decrease is caught by the ratchet rule. Elsewhere the position depends on the drafting and the Act. Ask for the review to be initiated by either party.
Sources and legislation
Legislation referred to:
- Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 11
- Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW), s 18
- Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic), s 35
- Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld), ss 27, 36A, 134
- Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA), s 22
- Leases (Commercial and Retail) Act 2001 (ACT), ss 46, 49
- Business Tenancies (Fair Dealings) Act 2003 (NT), s 28
- Fair Trading (Code of Practice for Retail Tenancies) Regulations 1998 (Tas), cl 12
Further reading:
- Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), current text
- Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW), official consolidation
- Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic), authorised version
- Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld), current text
- Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA), current text
- Leases (Commercial and Retail) Act 2001 (ACT), current text
- Business Tenancies (Fair Dealings) Act 2003 (NT), current text
- Tasmanian retail tenancy Code, current text
Related guides
This page is general information for retail tenants. It is not legal advice. Whether a lease is covered by retail tenancy legislation depends on the premises, the use, the state or territory and the exclusions in the relevant Act, so check the Act and get advice from a solicitor before you sign, exercise an option or withhold a payment. LeaseRoom is a document analysis service, not a law firm.